TIGblogs TIG | TIGblogs GROUP TIGBLOGS LOGIN SIGNUP
nick
nick
Tunisian reflections
About this event: World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) Phase Two
Related to country: Tunisia


This time last week I was still in Tunis. Now, the World Summit on the Information Society seems a bit like a dream - you know, those dreams involving 100 of your favourite people from different parts of your life (and indeed the world) doing extraordinary things in a surreal, slightly claustrophobic location – punctured momentarily with fleeting exchanges with world leaders, police with big guns, wonderful panoramic ocean views, and the bed-time lullaby that is BBC World.

It was fascinating to finally come to Tunisia, after hearing so much about this country - great, good, bad and ugly - for the last few years. The nation seemed to be taken over by the WSIS - schools were closed, public employees told to remain home, and half the population apparently newly hired as slightly menacing (but really rather lost?) security guards stationed three to every street corner. The absence of people (other than police) was unsettling and weird to say the least. And let's just say that the Tunisian National Flag Company seems to have done a recent roaring trade, with streets decked out in tens of thousands of coloured flags (totally beautiful, although I'm not sure how I'd feel if the UK lined every street of London with the Union Jack). The Tunisians put on a good show and everything (apart from giving the official bus drivers directions!) seemed to run smoothly.

Inside the Summit venue, it was quite easily to forget or ignore the reports outside (and in the global media) about Tunisia clamping down on freedom of expression just as it was hosting a Summit on the global Information Society. Certainly on the first day I spoke with a nice guy from Intel who seemed genuinely unaware of the human rights issues raised by local groups, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty and others. Although Summit delegates did get a minor taste for arbitrary procedures when plain clothed, un-badged guards would randomly block access between different rooms inside the Summit venue (Some of us tried to run/ram through but were mostly held back). Outside, towards the town centre, there were more serious protests and a counter-Summit organized by excluded human rights activists.

On the surface, with the police presence, pictures of President Ben-Ali ubiquitous, and a media that glowed in the government's triumph and little else, Tunisia certainly seemed totalitarian. At the same time, I got the sense (and was told by expats as well as local people) that there is little public dissatisfaction with the political situation. Certainly, I can appreciate that compared with its neighbours, Tunisia is an island of wealth, peace, religious moderation, and stability. You might say this is because it is not 'cursed' with much oil, or because it lacked the violent or confused de-colonisation of its neighbours. Or you might not care and just say 'well, things work pretty well here and I wouldn't want to live in someplace like Iraq.. or Algeria...or Egypt... or wherever'. In the areas I visited (mostly the more wealthy bits I guess) Tunisia seemed more apathetic than repressed. I wonder where resignation ends and apathy begins? And are there lessons for my own countries(s) and the rest of the world?

Reflecting on Tunisia might seem an odd way to start this blog - I had only a few moments to think about these questions, and it is true that Tunisia is sadly not the worst offender when it comes to Internet censorship. And the country - especially the Tunisian people- deserve everyone's thanks for hospitality and role in making this event happen. But just like I experienced in Johannesburg in 2002, the place - and it's political and economic reality- really does set the scene and the tone of your experience at a UN event.

On the Sunday after the Summit, Tom, Maja, Marouen and I headed to Korbus, a beautiful little hot spring on the beach a few hours out of the capitol, Tunis. It was great to be able to see a bit more of this country, feel its dynamic and unique cultural spirit and natural beauty. I'll have to come back and learn more - anyway I think about it, it was fascinating. And it was great to be able to spend short but very sweet time with these, and so many other good friends.

As for the Summit itself, I feel a deep sense of accomplishment. If you had asked me six weeks ago (as many did) whether I thought everything we had planned would come together, I could not have answered clearly. It is to Marouen's great credit that Youth participation in Tunis was smooth and dynamic. And this time last year, I would never have believed that the WSIS Youth Caucus would do so much in 2005, eclipsing even our work in 2003. From National & Rural Campaigns to the Award programs, the capacity building workshops, and the Youth Hub, we learnt so many lessons from the past, became more efficient and demonstrated once again a model for youth (indeed civil society) participation in global decision-making processes and forums that will be looked to and (for sure) replicated elsewhere. Titi and Robert, who took over from me as the Facilitators of the Caucus did an incredible job managing everyone's contributions as well as high expectations!

The week was also a celebration of TakingITGlobal's growth and maturity. This probably deserves an entire blog entry of its own, but I'm immensely proud of what TIG has achieved in its short five years. It was fitting that on the same day we held our fifth anniversary dinner in Tunis (great night!) TIG launched in its 7th language - Chinese, and reached (well, roughly) 100,000 members! The value of UN Summits is rarely (or never) just the formal documents developed but in their ability to bring great people together- that so many of TIG's active staff and members could attend and gain renewed strength and insight for the work of this unique network was fantastic. I'm also excited about new potential partnerships in the Middle East and Africa, as well TIG's new key role in Telecentre.org, a global support program for local community access initiatives [always a key part of the big TIG vision].

Now finally to the issues that WSIS was supposedly held to address. It's fair to say that in a formal sense, not much really was achieved at all - no huge new financial commitment to bridging the digital divide, no really new paradigm or international legal standards relating to the role of information in development and human rights. And not even really a clear road-map for how the Internet will be governed after the US decided it wasn't ready to cede final control over ICANN's functions - except for a vague new UN Forum that won't have teeth. But really, when was WSIS ever about ICANN anyway? As someone astutely pointed out to me, no one seems to be complaining about the dictatorship of Google, despite the fact that they have far more influence over how people use the net on a daily basis than the U.S., ICANN, or that perennial bogey, Microsoft.

At least however, as a result of WSIS and the great amount of media coverage it generated (including in influential publications) policy makers around the world and in many NGOs (such as those I work with) have started to take these issues much more seriously and are beginning to recognize that new information and communications technologies are truly transforming our educational, professional, political, and social lives. The quality of the discussion and decision-making, as well as the grassroots innovation, can only improve as a result.

It's the end of WSIS, but just the beginning of the story....

November 28, 2005 | 12:25 PM Comments  7 comments

Tags:
You must be logged in to add tags.


Comments

santaclos ugonwosu
November 28, 2005 | 2:36 PM
Epistle of Nick
Well Nick looks like an epistle on Tunis and the world summit just that it has no chapters or verses and it is not named after anyone, guess you should look for King James. Funny enough the City came back to life gently a day after the closing ceremony and.....
santaclos ugonwosu
November 28, 2005 | 3:08 PM
Oh!

Great thoughts Luke, sure no one is going to delete your comment I know. We actually have a few of you who would actually come up close and personal saying what they felt about the whole thing, anyway in some instances i share you view. The interactive thing i guess is a result of a few people being able to make the event so you se a whole new people all the time with a few familiar folks but thats part of the fun. Well the WSIS youth Caucus has come and gone. I think our next work should be "ACTION" dotting all the undotted......
lukecholerton Luke Cholerton-Bozier
November 28, 2005 | 6:37 PM

Email from Nick two minutes ago:

Just to let you know that yes, I did delete your comment on my blog
post. I put a lot of effort into that post and I didn't want to close
down thoughtful comment esp. on the issues of WSIS and the human rights
situation in Tunisia. I felt it was negatively affected by your comment.
It is the right obviously of any blog owner to moderate their own blog
how they want.

--

I thought this was an open space for debate. Obviously I was wrong.
nick Nick Moraitis
November 28, 2005 | 6:59 PM
Luke's postings
Just to say that Luke wrote a post which I deleted because I felt it wasn't in the spirit of my thread. I felt it personally attacked various people (although not naming them) and didn't really respond to what I had written. I hope that Luke uses his own blog to express his feelings and thoughts. I hope my blog remains a space in which firstly, I can reflect on issues important to me, and second, people can respond and comment. My blog is not intended to be a discussion board in general - I encoourage people to start their own blogs and use the TIG discussion board.
Jarra Jarra McGrath
November 28, 2005 | 10:12 PM

Great blog Nick :D Thanks for sharing :)
letsfindit Marc Ludwig
November 29, 2005 | 5:04 PM
finaly
hey nick,
it´s nice to find a blog of you also.
thanks for you sharing your experiences.

thanks you it all happened like this!!!

:-) greetings from germany
sofya Sofya
November 30, 2005 | 3:55 AM

Once again, your posting strongly encourages me to just stop one moment and take time to reflect on what WSIS means to me... How come the big city always swallows you so fast that you barely have a minute to face yourself and deal with your own thoughts? And I want to thank you ever so much for being always there and guiding me throught the whole NYC process. I was absolutely new to it, and I feel so much enriched with experience now that it's over...

Thank you, Nick.

And hope to see you on Dec. 12! :)
Nick Moraitis's Profile

Nick Moraitis's Friends


Latest Posts
You go Jess!
Sydney beginnings
I'm Getting Up.
Life update :P
Trend spotting

Monthly Archive

Change Language


Filter By Type
Events
Travel
Topics

Friends
'Gbenga Sesan
Adam Jantunen
Adrian Pintilie
alberto
Alex
Alex Markham
Alex McClelland
Alice Z
Amanda Diletti
Ana S. Pascual
Andy
Arief Prasetyo
Arun Khadka
asdf
Ashok Regmi
Axel Van Goud
Benjamin Quinto
Benjamin Wan
Bremley
Brent
Brett Solomon
Brian Smith
Cam
Catherine Kamping
Christine Oldfield
Damian Profeta
David Sontag
David Taylor
Den
Denis Duggan
Derek Martin
Diogo Andre
Eddy Bruin
edgar
Eliza
Emily Kumpel
Ezekiel Kevin Annan
Fernán Sepúlveda Santos
Franziska Seel
Gaurab Raj Upadhaya
Gustavo Noronha Silva
Ha Thi Lan Anh
Haseeb
Hayden
Hugh Switzer
Huiii
Huss
Itir Akdogan
Jack Butler
James Moody
Jarra McGrath
Jason Apostol
Jason Atkins
Jason Busch
Jason Crowe
Jennifer Corriero
Jennifer Cottes
Jeremy Silver
Jessica Rose
Jetze van der Ham
Jimmy Tam
Joel Solow
Jonah Wittkamper
Juan Diego Valenzuela
Kate Gilbert
kate raynes-goldie
Katia Berdichevsky
Keyvan Sayar
Kirsten Hagon
Kuba
Lesley Syetho
Lewis Best
Lisa
Lloyd Russell-Moyle
Luke Cholerton-Bozier
Madelaine Hamilton
Maitreyi Doshi
Maja Andjelkovic
Maja Lackova
Marc Ludwig
Marilyn Bromberg
Mark
Mark R
Marouen
Martin Kolesar
May Miller-Dawkins
Melina Laboucan-Massimo
Mervin J. Jebaraj
Michael Feller
Michael Furdyk
Mike
Myra Ng
Noor Alibhai
Nusrah Wali
Olivia Martin
Paul De La Merced
Pearl
petra
Raymond M. Kristiansen
Reggie
Richard Bartlett
rinalia abdul rahim
Rob
Robert Guerra
Robert Sagun
Robert Terdal Moe
ryann
Sarah Tierney
Sasha Costanza-Chock
Sofiah
Sonali
sunit
Susheela
Talesh
Tara
Tarek
Terah DeJong
Terri Willard
Thomas Biebl
Thomas Middleditch
TJ
Tom Burke
Trevor
TT
Umi Sabriah
Vanessa Currie
Willis
x
Yaz
Yves Khatchadourian
Zoe Fitzgerald

Links
Adbusters
GetUp!
Google
New York Times
Starbucks
The Age
Wikipedia


144877 views
Important Disclaimer